Blog March 9, 2024

How to Objectively Evaluate Warehouse Automation

By Marc Menard
March 9th | 2 min read

Marc’s Mechanics: Velocity x Process Matrix to Evaluate Automation

 

Want to automate your warehouse but don’t trust the equipment vendors to give you an unbiased recommendation?

You’re right to be skeptical. Equipment vendors sell equipment, and their ROI models often assume best-case scenarios and rarely account for the 80% of your SKUs that don’t justify automation.

An objective automation evaluation starts with understanding your operation, not with a vendor’s solution looking for a problem. Here’s how LIDD approaches automation assessment, focused on where technology actually drives value, not on what we’re trying to sell.

Warehouse Mechanics - tips & tricks from an supply chain expert

How do you justify the price tag for automation?

More often than not we see people gunning for a fully automated facility, only to be blindsided by a hefty price tag with little visibility on where the dollars are actually going. That’s why it’s essential to design your automation solutions with a laser focus on item combinations and processes.

Take a page out of Marc’s playbook as he shares his practical approach to evaluating where and when automation make sense based on item velocity.


 

Why Objectivity Matters in Automation Consulting

There’s a built-in conflict when the company evaluating your automation needs is also the company selling the equipment:

  • They sell solutions, not assessments. Their model requires recommending their products.
  • ROI models skew optimistic. Vendor projections assume ideal throughput, perfect uptime, smooth integration.
  • More automation means more sales, even if it’s not the right call for you.

LIDD doesn’t sell material-handling equipment. Our automation assessment is built around operational fit and financial return, which means:

  • We recommend manual or hybrid processes when automation doesn’t make sense.
  • We evaluate options across equipment vendors rather than steering you to one.
  • And because we also implement, we’re accountable for whether it actually works.

A Practical Approach to Automation

How do you decide which processes to automate?

Today, we’re rethinking how companies should look at automation in warehousing.

When you first think of automated facilities, you imagine these massive systems that can achieve enormous throughput and solve all your labor shortage issues. Then, you dive into the numbers and realize very quickly that the return doesn’t justify the spend. This is because you rarely see a single system capable of handling your entire SKU portfolio without busting the bank.

Start with Pareto’s law, 20% of SKUs generate 80% of volumes shipped and 80% of SKUs only generate 20% of volumes shipped. It’s easy to see how these SKU velocity categories should be analyzed separately. The same is true about warehouse processes. Not all processes warrant automation. When receiving products over the road, pallets may move in trailers making it difficult for AGVs to know their exact locations. On the other hand, AGVs can easily load trailer following a planogram. This is why when I evaluate warehouse automation; I like to look at an item velocity and process flows matrix.

What does “velocity” mean for automation decisions?

Velocity, in the context of supply chains, refers to the speed at which goods move through the various stages of production, distribution and consumption and the ability to change direction on short notice.

It is the heartbeat of an efficient and responsive supply chain, with different processes falling into categories like fast movers, medium movers, and slow movers.

When considering automation, companies use technology to accelerate velocity in supply chains, but the effectiveness depends on the process. Companies need to examine each process alongside the streams or population of items associated with it.

Which warehouse processes benefit most from automation?

Let’s take the example of picking/storage processes in your operations.

Fast-moving products in your warehouse demand an efficient high-bay storage solution, like goods-to-person picking or even robotic arms. Say a distribution center was catering to pharmaceuticals, here, a high-bay storage solution would address the rapid turnover of perishable goods, ensuring timely replenishment and order fulfillment.

On the other hand, for products that don’t fly off the shelves (slow-moving items), a high-density storage system is a valuable investment. In order to reduce space and walking distance, these goods can be stored densly using a VLM or autostore system.

Medium movers may increase the cost and effectiveness of either system, and may benefit from remaining in a conventional setup. For example, niche or specialized products that have moderate demand but require tailored handling or picking processes may not significantly benefit from automation. The adaptability and dexterity of manual operations can effectively manage such medium-moving SKUs without the need for extensive technological intervention.

The Velocity x Process Matrix in Practice

Velocity Receiving Storage Picking Shipping
Fast movers Automated depalletizing may help High-bay AS/RS or goods-to-person Goods-to-person or robotic picking Automated sortation
Medium movers Usually manual Conventional racking often best Zone picking, batch picking Manual or basic sortation
Slow movers Manual High-density storage (VLM, carousel) Pick-to-light or manual Manual

 

The key insight: Automation ROI tends to be strongest at the extremes: very fast movers and very slow movers. Medium-velocity SKUs often don’t justify the investment. This is where vendors oversell. They want to automate everything when selective automation delivers better returns.

For more on facility layout decisions that affect automation options, see Optimizing Warehouse Design: Pallet Racking Layouts.

What a Rigorous Automation Assessment Should Include

Whoever you hire, a credible automation evaluation should:

  1. Start from your operation, not a product. Your SKU velocity, order profiles, and labor constraints come before any equipment discussion.
  2. Model where automation doesn’t pay. A good assessment spends as much time ruling automation out as ruling it in. Automation ROI is usually strongest at the extremes, not the middle.
  3. Compare options across vendors. The right solution type should be chosen before the brand.
  4. Build the business case on your numbers. Real throughput, real uptime, real integration cost.
  5. Connect the analysis to execution. A recommendation that never gets implemented, or that falls apart on the floor, didn’t help you. The assessment should carry through to a workable plan.

Automation at LIDD

LIDD has extensive experience in assessing where technology does (or doesn’t) drive value across specific stages in the warehousing process. We help clients in designing automation solutions with a laser focus on item combinations and processes.

Don’t fool yourself into committing to a fully automated facility only to be blindsided by a hefty price tag with little visibility on where the dollars are actually going.

Want an objective assessment of where automation makes sense for your operation?

Take Our Automation Readiness Assessment or Request an Evaluation.

Let’s build world-class infrastructure together.

Book a Consultation

Speak with a Supply Chain Expert

Let’s talk about what you’re trying to solve.

Book a Consultation